| The world's dependence on crude oil for | | | | Renewable energy targets 166 |
| transportation is particularly marked, with the | | | | Kyoto Protocol 166 |
| International Energy Agency (IEA) estimating that | | | | European Union 166 |
| fuels from crude oil currently supply about 96% of | | | | US 169 |
| the worldwide energy demand for transport | | | | Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) 169 |
| purposes. | | | | Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS) 170 |
| As the world's population grows and developing | | | | Developing nations 171 |
| countries look to expand their economies, this | | | | Biofuels targets 172 |
| insatiable demand for fossil fuels is unlikely to show | | | | Biofuels policy overview by region 173 |
| any sign of easing, with oil and gas accounting for | | | | The European Union 173 |
| 60% of the world's increasing energy demand | | | | Biofuels Directive 173 |
| between now and 2030. Furthermore, with most | | | | Directive 2003/96/EC 174 |
| significant reserves of fossil fuels unevenly distributed | | | | Incentives for biofuels 174 |
| throughout the world, energy security is set to | | | | Tax incentives 175 |
| become an increasingly critical economic and political | | | | The United States 177 |
| issue over the coming decades. Real or perceived | | | | US Energy Policy Act 2005 177 |
| disruptions to the global supply of fossil fuels – | | | | Brazil 178 |
| notably crude oil – are likely to grow in frequency | | | | Proalcool Program 178 |
| and cause wild fluctuations in the price of energy, as | | | | India 179 |
| they have done so in the past. | | | | Biodiesel policy 179 |
| However, one of the most pressing reasons for | | | | Bioethanol policy 180 |
| seeking alternative sources of energy and fuel lies in | | | | China 181 |
| the form of climate change. The combustion of fossil | | | | National Biomass Ethanol Gasoline Project 181 |
| fuels releases carbon dioxide (CO2), a potent | | | | The Renewable Energy Law of the People's Republic |
| ‘greenhouse gas' (GHG), which are considered to | | | | of China 181 |
| be responsible for ‘global warming'. According to | | | | Chapter conclusion 182 |
| the IEA, if no changes are made to the world's | | | | Report conclusion 183 |
| existing energy economy, related emissions of CO2 | | | | Abbreviations 186 |
| will grow marginally faster than energy use, meaning | | | | Energy content and conversion rates 187 |
| that by 2030 global CO2 emissions will be more than | | | | Index 189 |
| 50% higher than today. Over two-thirds of that | | | | List of Figures |
| projected increase in emissions is expected to come | | | | Figure 2.1: World renewable energy, 2008 30 |
| from emerging economies, such as India, China – | | | | Figure 2.2: Current and predicted EU biomass |
| both of which are set to rely heavily on coal-based | | | | resources (Mtoe/y) 33 |
| power stations to drive their rapidly developing | | | | Figure 2.3: Current and potential US biomass |
| economies. | | | | resources (Million dry tonnes/y), 2005 34 |
| Key features of this report | | | | Figure 2.4: Potential power generation from biomass |
| • Analysis of biofuels by type, resources available, | | | | among ASEAN countries (MW) 36 |
| production volumes, production technology capacity | | | | Figure 2.5: Breakdown of currently available biomass in |
| installed. | | | | China by type 37 |
| • Market projections to 2020, including an | | | | Figure 2.6: Maximum regional bioenergy production |
| evaluation of energy type and national and | | | | potential, 2050 38 |
| international growth potential. | | | | Figure 2.7: Typical oil extraction from 100kg of oil |
| • Overview of trends impacting on and shaping | | | | seeds (kg) 44 |
| innovation in the energy market. | | | | Figure 3.8: Global biosphere, 1998 60 |
| • New renewable energy technology analysis | | | | Figure 3.9: Biofuels time period to availability (years), |
| including innovation, capacity and biofuels investment. | | | | 2009 61 |
| Scope of this report | | | | Figure 3.10: Cushing, OK WTI Oil Spot Price FOB |
| • Achieve a quick and comprehensive | | | | prices (Dollars per Barrel), 1986-2009 66 |
| understanding of how global market trends and | | | | Figure 4.11: Relative competitiveness of alternative |
| legislation are influencing the development of the | | | | energies in five years, 2009 69 |
| biofuels industry. | | | | Figure 4.12: Relative economic competitiveness of |
| • Realize up to date competitive intelligence | | | | biofuels now and in the next five years, 2009 70 |
| through a comprehensive review of global markets in | | | | Figure 4.13: What proportion of global fuel production |
| the biofuels energy industry between 1990 and 2008. | | | | will biofuels account for by 2020? 71 |
| • Assess the emerging trends in the biofuels | | | | Figure 4.14: Within how long will biofuels account for |
| industry – Biomethanol, Hydro Thermal Upgrading | | | | the primary source of global fuel production? 72 |
| (HTU) diesel, Fischer-Tropsch (FT) diesel, | | | | Figure 4.15: Which regions will lead the development |
| Lignocellulosic ethanol, Algae fuel, Photo-bioreactors | | | | of biofuels over the next five years? 73 |
| carbon emission absorption. | | | | Figure 4.16: How important will the following factors |
| Key Market Issues | | | | be in driving the biofuels market over the next five |
| • Environmental regulations: Environmental targets | | | | years? 74 |
| set to control Carbon dioxide emissions globally are | | | | Figure 4.17: How important will the following factors |
| creating a path for lower carbon emission fuel | | | | be in inhibiting the biofuels market over the next five |
| technologies. | | | | years? 75 |
| • Energy security:- Oil pricing structures are volatile | | | | Figure 4.18: Biofuels impact on global food crop prices, |
| and uncontrollable, due to the majority imported from | | | | 2009 76 |
| non-domestic countries. This volatility is likely to | | | | Figure 5.19: Projected world energy demand to 2030 |
| increase as reserves of the natural resources decline. | | | | (Mtoe) 82 |
| • Resource allocation: Some of the currently | | | | Figure 5.20: Growth in energy demand by region |
| available biofuels have a number of disadvantages | | | | (2000-2030) 83 |
| that are related to their feedstock. The current costs | | | | Figure 5.21: Projected worldwide oil consumption |
| of rapeseed biodiesel and ethanol from cereals or | | | | (million barrels per day), 2005-2025 84 |
| beets are much higher than the costs of petrol or | | | | Figure 5.22: Average annual oil price (US$ per barrel), |
| diesel, with substantial subsidies required to make | | | | 2008 89 |
| them competitive. Second generation biofuels have | | | | Figure 5.23: Opting for green energy is one |
| been developed due to limitations of first generation | | | | behavioural aspect of rising environmental attitudes |
| biofuels, primarily that the resources used threatens | | | | 90 |
| food supplies. | | | | Figure 5.24: The potential biomass availability of EU15, |
| | | | AC10 and/or Europe according to five studies (left |
| Key findings from this report | | | | part of the figure) 94 |
| • Worldwide production of biodiesel reached | | | | Figure 6.25: Cost of distribution and dispensation of |
| 11,016m liters per annum, with the EU representing | | | | various fuels from a central production facility to a |
| 72% of that global biodiesel production and | | | | filling station (€/GJ) 105 |
| consumption. | | | | Figure 6.26: Costs of various biofuels at the filling |
| • Germany, France, Italy, the UK and Austria | | | | station using existing technology (2004) 106 |
| were the largest biofuels consumers in the EU in | | | | Figure 6.27: An algae production process, 2009 109 |
| 2008. The USDA forecasts that biofuels consumption | | | | Figure 6.28: Algal fuel capacity projections 2009-2014, |
| in the EU will continue to grow throughout 2009, | | | | 2009 112 |
| despite the economic downturn. The increase is a | | | | Figure 6.29: Gasoline ethanol (kpa/%v/v), 2008 114 |
| result of mandates and tax incentives. | | | | Figure 6.30: Car costs (€) and fuel efficiencies (km |
| • There are currently 192 bioethanol production | | | | GJ of fuel) of passenger cars by fuel and engine |
| plants in the US, which together have a production | | | | system 115 |
| capacity of 36,300m liters per year. | | | | Figure 7.31: Worldwide biofuels fuel production volume |
| • The US accounted for 24% of the global | | | | (billion liters), 2008 123 |
| biodiesel market in 2008 – accounting for 2,650m | | | | Figure 7.32: Global bioethanol production growth |
| liters per annum. | | | | (thousand tons of oil equivalent), 1998-2008 126 |
| • It is also notable that Brazil is by far the world's | | | | Figure 7.33: Top bioethanol producing countries |
| largest exporter of ethanol at 3.5bn liters (from | | | | (thousand tons of oil equivalent), 2008 127 |
| production of 19bn liters). Production is estimated by | | | | Figure 7.34: Biodiesel (million L/a), 2009 129 |
| the IEA to increase to over 4bn liters in 2009. Most | | | | Figure 7.35: Bioethanol in Europe (million L/a), 2008 131 |
| exports go to the US, Europe, Korea and Japan. | | | | Figure 7.36: Biodiesel production in Europe (million liters |
| Key questions answered | | | | annum), 2009 136 |
| • What are the drivers shaping and influencing | | | | Figure 7.37: EU market share of biodiesel production in |
| development in the biofuel industry? | | | | 2008 (%), 2009 138 |
| • How will biofuels production share perform to | | | | Figure 7.38: Projected US ethanol production (billions |
| 2020? What are the opportunities? | | | | of gallons), 2006-2012 142 |
| • What are the forecast market growth rates | | | | Figure 7.39: US ethanol market revenue forecast |
| 2008-2030? Which markets will see the highest value | | | | ($bn), 2006-2012 143 |
| growth and which the highest volume growth? | | | | Figure 7.40: US bioethanol development (million L/a), |
| • Which regions and countries offer the greatest | | | | 2009 144 |
| opportunity for growth? | | | | Figure 7.41: US biodiesel (million L/a), 2009 147 |
| Table of Contents : | | | | Figure 7.42: Brazil biofuels development (million L/a), |
| Table of Contents | | | | 2009 150 |
| Next Generation Biofuels | | | | Figure 8.43: Renewable fuels targets in the US (billions |
| Executive summary 14 | | | | of gallons per year), 2006-2012 170 |
| What are biofuels? 14 | | | | Figure 8.44: EU biofuels targets, 2008 174 |
| Next generation biofuels 15 | | | | List of Tables |
| Industry forecasts for biofuels 16 | | | | Table 2.1: World renewable energy, 2008 29 |
| Biofuels drivers and inhibitors 17 | | | | Table 2.2: Population, energy consumption and |
| The biofuels economy 18 | | | | biomass contribution in selected regions, 2005 31 |
| Biofuels market size and forecasts 19 | | | | Table 2.3: Current and predicted EU biomass |
| Biofuels policies and regulations 20 | | | | resources (Mtoe/y) 32 |
| Chapter 1 Introduction 22 | | | | Table 2.4: Current and potential US biomass resources |
| Audience 22 | | | | (Million dry tons/y), 2005 34 |
| How to read this report 22 | | | | Table 2.5: Potential power generation from biomass |
| Chapter 2 What are biofuels? 26 | | | | among ASEAN countries (MW) 35 |
| Summary 26 | | | | Table 2.6: Breakdown of currently available biomass in |
| World energy demand 27 | | | | China by type 37 |
| Climate change 27 | | | | Table 2.7: Maximum regional bioenergy production |
| Renewable energy 28 | | | | potential, 2050 38 |
| Biomass 30 | | | | Table 2.8: Typical oil extraction from 100kg of oil |
| What is biomass? 30 | | | | seeds (kg) 44 |
| Population, energy consumption and biomass 31 | | | | Table 3.9: Comparison of first and second generation |
| Regional resources 32 | | | | biofuels 48 |
| What are biofuels? 39 | | | | Table 3.10: Biofuels comparison (Liters of oil yields |
| Solid biofuels 40 | | | | (hectares/year)), to 2009 59 |
| Liquid biofuels 40 | | | | Table 3.11: Viable Bio-SPK feedstock alternatives, |
| Gas biofuels 41 | | | | 2009 61 |
| Biofuels in current use 41 | | | | Table 3.12: Fuel property comparisons: Neat, 2009 63 |
| Ethanol 41 | | | | Table 3.13: Fuel property comparisons: Blends, 2009 |
| Distribution, storage and blending 42 | | | | 64 |
| End-use 42 | | | | Table 5.14: Projected world energy demand to 2030 |
| Biodiesel 42 | | | | 81 |
| Distribution, storage, blending 43 | | | | Table 5.15: Growth in energy demand by region |
| End-use 43 | | | | (2000-2030) 82 |
| Chapter 3 Next generation – advanced biofuels | | | | Table 5.16: Projected worldwide oil consumption |
| 46 | | | | (million barrels per day), 2005-2025 84 |
| Summary 46 | | | | Table 5.17: CO2 equivalent emissions savings from |
| Introduction 47 | | | | biofuels (g/km), 2006 85 |
| Second generation biofuels 49 | | | | Table 5.18: Average annual oil price (US$ per barrel), |
| Second generation biofuels under development 51 | | | | 2008 88 |
| Biohydrogen 51 | | | | Table 5.19: Key barriers for biofuels 91 |
| BioDME 51 | | | | Table 6.20: Production costs of biofuels from various |
| Biomethanol 51 | | | | crops 103 |
| Butonal and Isobutanol 52 | | | | Table 6.21: Cost of distribution and dispensation of |
| Dimethylfuran (DMF) 52 | | | | various fuels from a central production facilityto a |
| Hydro Thermal Upgrading (HTU) diesel 52 | | | | filling station (€/GJ) 104 |
| Fischer-Tropsch fuels 52 | | | | Table 6.22: Costs of various biofuels at the filling |
| Bioconversion of biomass to mixed alcohol fuels 53 | | | | station using existing technology (2004) 106 |
| Wood diesel 53 | | | | Table 6.23: Cost comparison of biofuels with gasoline |
| Key players in second generation biofuels 53 | | | | fossil fuels 107 |
| Market possibilities for second generation biofuels 54 | | | | Table 6.24: Cost estimates of various biofuels at the |
| Third generation biofuel 55 | | | | filling station using future technology, post- 2010 108 |
| Algae fuel 55 | | | | Table 6.25: Cost of harvesting, dewatering and drying |
| Background 55 | | | | algae, 2009 110 |
| Limitations of previous biofuels 56 | | | | Table 6.26: Top biofuels companies, 2009 111 |
| Algae types 56 | | | | Table 6.27: Algal fuel capacity projections 2009-2014, |
| Algae cultivation 57 | | | | 2009 112 |
| Photo-bioreactors 57 | | | | Table 7.28: Comparison of worldwide fuel production |
| Closed loop systems 57 | | | | from hydrocarbon sources versus biomass sources, |
| Open pond systems 58 | | | | 2005 122 |
| Algae fuel potential 58 | | | | Table 7.29: Worldwide biofuels fuel production volume |
| Development timeline 60 | | | | (bn liters), 2008 122 |
| Aircraft biofuels testing 61 | | | | Table 7.30: Amounts of raw materials to meet |
| Key players for third generation biofuel 64 | | | | worldwide fuel demand, 2005 123 |
| Market possibilities for algae biofuel 65 | | | | Table 7.31: Global bioethanol production (thousand |
| Chapter 4 Forecasts for biofuels 68 | | | | tons of oil equivalent), 2008 125 |
| Summary 68 | | | | Table 7.32: Biodiesel (million L/a), 2008 128 |
| Introduction 69 | | | | Table 7.33: Bioethanol in Europe (million L/a), 2008 130 |
| Economic competitiveness of biofuels and biomass 69 | | | | Table 7.34: EU bioethanol production, supply and |
| Biofuels technology development 72 | | | | demand (1,000MT) 132 |
| Biofuels drivers and inhibitors 73 | | | | Table 7.35: EU bioethanol production - number of |
| Chapter conclusion 76 | | | | plants and capacity (1,000 MT) 132 |
| Chapter 5 Biofuels drivers and inhibitors 80 | | | | Table 7.36: Feedstock use for bioethanol production |
| Summary 80 | | | | (1,000MT) 133 |
| Market background 81 | | | | Table 7.37: EU bioethanol consumption – main |
| Drivers of the biofuels market 85 | | | | consumers (1,000 MT) 134 |
| Greenhouse gases and environmental concerns 85 | | | | Table 7.38: EU bioethanol and gasoline consumption |
| Regulatory incentives/pressure 86 | | | | (Ktoe) 134 |
| Concern about energy security 88 | | | | Table 7.39: Biodiesel production in Europe (millions liters |
| Rising cost of existing fuel supplies 88 | | | | annum), 2009 135 |
| Consumer pressure 90 | | | | Table 7.40: EU Biodiesel production – number of |
| Inhibitors of the biofuels market 91 | | | | plants and capacity (1,000 MT) 137 |
| The biofuels economy 92 | | | | Table 7.41: EU market share of biodiesel production in |
| Sustainability concerns and the rising price of food | | | | 2008 (%), 2009 138 |
| crops 92 | | | | Table 7.42: Feedstock use for biodiesel production |
| Limited biofuels infrastructure 93 | | | | (1,000MT), 2009 139 |
| Biomass and land availability 94 | | | | Table 7.43: EU biodiesel consumption (1,000MT), 2009 |
| Chapter 6 The biofuels economy 98 | | | | 140 |
| Summary 98 | | | | Table 7.44: EU biodiesel and diesel consumption |
| Introduction 99 | | | | (Ktoe), 2009 140 |
| American market 99 | | | | Table 7.45: Projected US ethanol production (billions |
| American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 | | | | of gallons), 2006-2012 141 |
| 100 | | | | Table 7.46: US ethanol market revenue forecast |
| Biofuels new direction away from corn-based ethanol | | | | (US$bn), 2006-2012 142 |
| 101 | | | | Table 7.47: US bioethanol development (million L/a), |
| The biofuels economy 102 | | | | 2009 143 |
| Production costs 102 | | | | Table 7.48: Existing and future ethanol capacity in the |
| Cost of distribution 103 | | | | US, 2009 145 |
| Cost at filling station 105 | | | | Table 7.49: US biodiesel (million L/a), 2009 146 |
| Third generation algae fuel costs 108 | | | | Table 7.50: Ethanol profile comparison of the US and |
| Algae fuel leading players costs comparison 110 | | | | Brazil (2006) 148 |
| Transport fuel blends 113 | | | | Table 7.51: Brazil biofuels development (million L/a), |
| Car costs and fuel efficiency 114 | | | | 2009 149 |
| Chapter conclusion 116 | | | | Table 7.52: Brazilian biodiesel production, supply and |
| Chapter 7 Biofuels market size and forecasts 120 | | | | demand (January-December, 000 Liters), 2009 151 |
| Summary 120 | | | | Table 7.53: Brazilian fuel consumption matrix (000 m3) |
| Worldwide energy demand 121 | | | | 151 |
| Biofuels market sizing 124 | | | | Table 7.54: Brazilian soybeans and products production |
| Worldwide 124 | | | | (000 hectares, 000 metric tons) 152 |
| Ethanol 124 | | | | Table 7.55: Brazilian cotton and products production |
| Biodiesel 127 | | | | (000 hectares, 000 metric tons) 152 |
| Europe 130 | | | | Table 7.56: Projected demand and supply of ethanol |
| Ethanol 130 | | | | in India for 5% blend with gasoline 153 |
| Biodiesel 134 | | | | Table 7.57: India's ethanol requirement for 5% |
| US 141 | | | | blending with gasoline sugar 154 |
| Ethanol 141 | | | | Table 7.58: India's production & distribution of |
| Biodiesel 145 | | | | molasses and alcohol/ethanol in sugar (million Tons/ |
| Brazil 147 | | | | million Liters), 2008 155 |
| Ethanol 147 | | | | Table 7.59: Projected demand for gasoline and diesel |
| Biodiesel 150 | | | | in India to 2012 (MT) 156 |
| India 153 | | | | Table 7.60: Diesel and biodiesel demand in India using |
| India's fuel economy 153 | | | | Jatropha (MT) 157 |
| Ethanol 153 | | | | Table 7.61: China's major biodiesel plants production |
| Biodiesel 155 | | | | capacity (MT), 2008 159 |
| China 157 | | | | Table 8.62: Biofuels infrastructure profiles,Q209 165 |
| China's fuel economy 157 | | | | Table 8.63: Mechanisms to incentivize renewable |
| Ethanol 157 | | | | energy generation 166 |
| Biodiesel 158 | | | | Table 8.64: EU renewable energy targets for 2020 |
| China working with the US for biofuels development | | | | (%) 168 |
| 159 | | | | Table 8.65: Renewable fuels targets in the US (billions |
| Chapter 8 Biofuels policies and regulations 162 | | | | of gallons per year), 2006-2012 169 |
| Summary 162 | | | | Table 8.66: Biofuels energy targets 172 |
| Introduction 164 | | | | Table 8. |
| Policy frameworks 165 | | | | |